"Joining Hands, the way forward"
by Valéry Nodem, Coordinator RELUFA, Cameroon
The theme for this year's Joining Hands Consultation was: “Joining Hands, the way forward”. One specific goal of the event was for JH partners to reflect on how to engage with each other in global campaigns, each of us within our respective context, shifting from project-oriented activities to a true, worldwide coalition of international and US based Joining Hands networks campaigning together on common global issues. |
Global JH Campaign on Natural Resources
by Valéry Nodem, Cameroon
Global JH Campaign on Land
by Chenoa Stock, Sri Lanka
Global JH Campaign on Water
by Andrew Kang-Bartlett, PHP |

JH staff Alexa Smith facilitates a session to discern Global Joining Hands Campaigns |
|
|
by Valéry Nodem, RELUFA Coordinator, Cameroon
Since the PCUSA officially joined the international Publish What You Pay (PWYP) Campaign by decision of the General Assembly in June 2008, the International Event in Orange was an opportune moment to discuss how to move this campaign within the Presbyterian Church (USA). Besides the presence of the Cameroonian Joining Hands partners, Samuel Nguiffo, Director of the Center for Environment and Development, and RELUFA Coordinator Valery Nodem, also Sarah Pray had been invited as the Coordinator of the PWYP US branch, to help the reflection on how to build a global campaign within JH on Natural Resources.

Samuel Nguiffo explains the need for pressure on financial Institutions to be held accountable for their support of resource extraction projects that do not meet standards of transparency and social responsibility |
Many less developed countries are attracting significant foreign investments for the exploration and extraction of their natural resources such as oil, gas, and mineral wealth. Revenues from these investments make their way to governments in the form of taxes, fees and other payments. If this revenue were effectively and transparently managed, it could serve as a basis for successful growth and poverty reduction. However, the state and other institutions that manage these resources are often, in practice, unaccountable to the parliaments and citizens of their countries. Revenues from resource extraction are disclosed neither by the governments nor the companies involved. This lack of accountability facilitates embezzlement, corruption and revenue misappropriation. In extreme cases, access to resources fuels regional conflict and the resulting disorder is exploited to facilitate further large-scale misappropriation of state assets.
Mining, gas, and oil companies cannot control how governments spend taxes, royalties and fees. But they do have a responsibility to disclose the payments they make so citizens can hold their governments accountable. Companies that fail to do so are complicit in the disempowerment of the people of the countries to which the resources belong.
PWYP is an international transparency campaign requesting from companies involved in the extractive industries sector to disclose all the payments made to the governments of countries where they operate.
We discussed why it is important at this very moment for the church to be part of the struggle for transparency, where the church should apply the pressure for change and how it could mobilize its constituency to voice their concerns.
Sarah Pray presented the Extractive Industry Transparency Disclosure Act, which through PWYP US has been introduced to the Senate as an amendment to the Foreign Corrupt Practice Act. The purpose of the Bill is to require from companies registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to publish their payments to foreign governments for oil, gas and minerals, which would reduce risks for the investors, level the playing field for American companies and contribute to global efforts to fight corruption and reduce poverty and instability in oil producing countries. She explained that nearly all competitive oil, gas and mining companies are registered with the SEC, and as such, the Bill represents an important step forward in creating a truly global standard for transparency.
Many Presbyterians present at the event endorsed the Bill during the event by signing it, supporting this way RELUFA's effort.

Valéry Nodem discussing the need for a security protocol |
A Global Joining Hands Campaign should include the concern for the security of Joining Hands activists, particularly when they deal with sensitive issues such as the extraction of natural wealth.
- Overseas partners should speak openly about risks and threats related to their activities
- In the case of a threat, overseas partners will inform their network members as well as their JH partners in the US,
- PHP is going to work with each network involved in this issue to develop a national-level security protocol.
- Each presbytery will make an e-mail listing for the US ambassador to the country where they have partners, the country’s ambassador to the US, the president or prime minister, their US senator or congressional representatives. This list should be kept updated as they change frequently.
- Participating Presbyteries and networks will start studying materials related to the extractive industries’ topic:
- In response to this reading material, participants will compile recommendations on values missing in the above mentioned documents. They will send their suggestions for values they may want to see inserted in the bank loan process to Alexa, who will forward them to the campaign leader.
- Participants are asked to do a hypothetical investigation into their own communities, such as:
- what regulations would govern a corporation running an oil pipeline thru their own residential neighborhoods?
- what EPA guidelines would need to be followed if a corporation was spewing poisons there?
- how do cities displace people to make way for progress?
- They are encouraged to look at investors rules and procedures before giving loans to companies and to look at all the procedures for the World Bank, or other institutions governing the extractive sector, for example the World Bank operational directives, the Ecuador principles, the Wolfsberg Principles, etc.
- PHP is going to work with each network involved in this issue to develop a national-level security protocol.
- Each presbytery will make and update frequently an e-mail listing for the US ambassador to the country where they have partners, the country’s ambassador to the US, the president or prime minister, their US senator or congressional representatives.
- Valery Nodem will help coordinate the development of a Global Joining Hands Campaign on Natural Resources.
|
Global Campaign on Land
by Chenoa Stock, JH Companionship Facilitator, Sri Lanka
Gathered to discern the prospect of a global land campaign, the Joining Hands partners participating in this discussion discovered many common issues that are affecting those within our Networks and beyond.
We brainstormed the vast spectrum of problems and the present situation in our respective countries, and the following were shared:
- Land Agrarian Reform – land tenure
- Issues with land sold as real estate
- Care of land should include biodiversity and alternative methods of crop production
- Lack of access to resources - Agriculture, Water
- How this affects livelihood
- Displacement of people from their own land, due to war or economic ‘development’, military occupation, cash crops, golf courses, tourist industry, agro-business, commercial crops
- High Security Zones, Special Economic Zones
- Appropriation of communal land for the purpose of privatization
- “imminent domain” – US parallel expropriation
- poor people are forced to sell their land
- lose inheritance – property increase
- Issues of ownership – long term real estate
- Try to get land from government – need deeds, but none are given
- ** Neocolonialism – government is the first enemy of the people, and first to exploit the people

Siva Prakasam speaks about land rights for marginalized Dalits in India |
We came to see that land issues are not only a nation’s individual problem, but they are also connected worldwide. These global land issues were also discussed. Some of them involve the policies and work of the World Trade Organization (WTO), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the World Bank, the deception by these organizations, and the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSP), which are required by the IMF and World Bank before a country can be considered for debt relief within the HIPC programme. The global trend include also the increase in Chinese businesses buying up land in Africa and Peru.
As the discussion progressed, the meaning of land, beyond these tangible issues, was also mentioned. We all believe that land rights should be an inclusive concept and one that is taken up to protect the rights of all people. Land is not only for production, but is also sacred, spiritual, and sovereign.

Herman Kumara explains how, in light of the aftermath of the Tsunami, Land issues are of great concern to Sri Lanka Joining Hands partners. |
While brainstroming, we heard from each other about the many land campaigns that are already being carried out around the world. Some of these include the ICAARD (International Conference on Agrarian Reform and Rural Development) Process of the UN, movements in Africa and Latin America, an upcoming Asian Land Conference in Sri Lanka in June, 2009, Via Campesina (a Worldwide Peasants Movement), and a Family Farmers Movement. Though these campaigns and projects may focus on different issues of land, it was seen that partnerships for campaigns or resources for ideas on how to build our own were readily available.
Upon discovering the commonalities among each network, the next steps for action were planned. Some of these tasks, in order to build a strong JH Global Campaign, include:
- Sharing of information within and between networks
- Organization of advocacy activities
- Development of education resources
- Participation in preparation of PRSP
- Coordination of a campaign in connection with resource institutions
- Link various country campaigns
- Use test case for study and attack
- Identify and link with key players like:
The following resources were considered useful for building a global campaign:
- Joseph Stiglitz - American economist and a professor at Columbia University. He is known for his critical view of the management of globalization, free-market economists (whom he calls "free market fundamentalists") and some international institutions like the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. (Wikipedia)
- Armatiya Sen - Indian economist, philosopher, and a winner of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1998, "for his contributions to welfare economics" for his work on famine, human development theory, welfare economics, the underlying mechanisms of poverty, and political liberalism.(Wikipedia)
- The Oakland Institute- Progressive policy think tank working to increase public participation and to promote fair debate on critical social, economic, and environmental issues. Anuradha Mittal (who spoke at the conference) is the Executive Director
To begin a Global Joining Hands Campaign on Land, we must denounce these past ways and organize resistance by challenging the IMF and WTO and documenting its failure. We should each meet our local situation, while also connecting with and learning from each other, in order to build an awareness and education on the issues. Each network must also prioritize on which campaign it has the capacity to focus.
We then assigned country roles to those who were interested in involving in this campaign. Below are the countries, their networks, and their roles.
Sri Lanka/Praja Abhilasha
- Identify and link w/ key players
- coordinate the campaign (link w/ resource institutions)
South Africa/Sisonke
- Sharing and gathering information within and between networks
India/Chethana:
- Organizing Advocacy
- Develop Education Resources
As we concluded our discussion, ideas for campaign names were shared. These included Land for Life, Reclaiming Land for life, and Land is Life. It was decided that Land is Life was the most appropriate and dynamic for our campaign work.
|
To promote the Global Joining Hands Campaign on Land and encourage exchange between participating networks and other interested audiences, Indian Joining Hands partners opened an interactive website: www.bhoomimatha.com |
|
As the sharing of information continues, we look forward to building a stronger linkage and communication among these networks. It is our hope that we can move beyond our discussion and put our words into action, in order to protect the rights of people and share with the world that Joining Hands believes that ‘Land is Life’. |
|
by Andrew Kang-Bartlett, PHP Associate for National Hunger Concerns
Many Joining Hands networks participated in the energized meeting on worldwide networking on the issue of water. Together we identified components of a strategy to move forward.
What is our General Campaign Strategy?
1. identify common principles related to water access, quality and privatization
2. find platforms to tell stories, share experiences and models
3. collaborate with and join water organizations
4. develop a clear communication strategy
Which groups and resources could be recommended?
• Organizations: - Our World is Not For Sale, Water Warriors, Red Agua (Western Hemisphere), Ecumenical Water Working Group (convened by Church World Service)
• Book: Blue Gold by Maude Barlow
What are some principles for campaigning on water?
• Sustainable water for all of life
• Equitable distribution and access to water
• Challenge the concept of water ownership; protect against water theft and privatization
• Resist policies that result in displacement without popular consent and sufficient compensation
• Promote the concept of national water sovereignty
• Water not a commodity, but as a basic human right
• Oppose and prevent water pollution in industry, the extractive industry, and agriculture
• No compromise of human water consumption and ecosystem integrity to profit-making of corporations
• Increase availability, quality and access to water
• Pressure to increase funding for sustainable water systems
What are some common values?
• Patrimony of humans and life
• Water as a gift of God
• Water as a common good
• Water is life
• Heritage of creation
• Healthy, safe environment
• Sacred rivers, sacredness of water, spirituality of water bodies
What types of initiatives belong in a Global Campaign?
• Education about current Global Water issues and campaigns
• Share our experiences and campaign with rest of Joining Hands and PCUSA
• Share information, etc. with local groups to support them in their efforts
• Assess our capacity to be involved at different levels in a global campaign
• Share models that transcend one country
Pros/Cons/Questions:
• How would we connect with existing local and global water campaigns? What would be our contribution to them?
• How would this campaign link with other key concerns of JH networks?
• How do our local campaigns tie into global citizenship and can they be impacted by a global campaign?
• How can we strengthen and build our own networks by connecting and supporting each other’s campaign efforts?
• What are our limits? What energies can we give? Would we be spread too thin?
• How do we organize to promote local control?
• How do we link? Only Presbyteries? Other connections?
What is the message (rallying point)?
• Water belongs to and is for all
• Pollution, contamination
• Access to safe water
• Anti-privatization
• Right to water
How we can begin to network on global water issues?
• JH Internet Newsletter: Start small – a column on the water campaign
• Learn and research about global water campaigns
• Conference Calls
• Email Group
• Communication/Security Tree – “pushes” – for urgent issues and support; notify of security alerts
• Identify a JH Water Point Person : Andrew Kang Bartlett – Andrew.kangbartlett@pcusa.org
What are some of our existing water connections?
Existing water connections: McCloud ---- Sacramento Presbytery ---- India ---- Sri Lanka - - San Francisco Presbytery --- Cascades --- Cuba Presby Church - - UMAVIDA - - Peru - - Giddings-Lovejoy Presbytery |
|
|